Air force intended the f22 to be part of a highendlowend mix with the f35, much like the f15 and f16 were the combination in the 1990s, only the f22f35 combination will be much harder to. Russias new t50 fighter still cant compete with the f 35. American fighter pilots air force, navy, and marine are largely in agreement that, while the f22 is a superior airtoair fighter, the new f35 is a better, if still flawed, allround combat aircraft. I was viewing another forum where some guy is arguing that an f14 newest model could take onbeat an f22. Heres what ive learned so far dogfighting in the f35. The f 35 is reported to be stealthier than the f 22 from the front, although it is generally said to have a less uniform rcs than the f 22. The f 35 also lacks a key element of the f 22 raptor, now appearing the most modern russian jets. F 35 is intended to replace the f 16 and is promoted as f 16s successor. Comparison of f35 and f22 technology f35 lightning ii. Air force intended the f 22 to be part of a highendlowend mix with the f 35, much like the f 15 and f 16 were the combination in the 1990s, only the f 22 f 35 combination will be much harder to detect and defend against. Opponents claim that the project is vastly more expensive than the european eurofighter or the swedish jas gripen.
Intelligence support for the f35a lightning ii capt stephanie anne fraioli, usaf. Comparing chengdu j20 with f22, f35 and supak fa or t. The f35 is reported to be stealthier than the f22 from the front, although it is generally said to have a less uniform rcs than the f22. The joint strike fighter is the next generation fighter to support the us navy, air force, marine corps, united kingdom and defense partners in australia, canada, denmark, italy, the netherlands, norway, and turkey. The f35 reacts quicker to my pedal inputs than the.
In any event, the f 35 will outclass a rafale, f 15e, or eurofighter, but not the f 22. In comparison the a10, along with the enormous cannon it is built around, can. Battle of the xplanes jsf documentary from 2003 lockheed. So the f35 will never see a su35 on radar screen before the su35 see the f35. Two f119pw100 turbofan engines power the f22 raptor. Many have compared the f22 to the f35 but that comparison is unfair. Mar 01, 2003 ive noticed that the f 35 joint strike fighter and the f 22 raptor, both of which are in development by lockheed martin, look strikingly similar. Over here in norway, there is a current debate about norways planned purchase of the american f35. While behind schedule, the program has been a top air force priority for more than a decade and until recently, was expected to remain usafs only fighter program. F35 joint strike fighter and the f22 raptor popular science. This airplane, with its fly by wire technology, is super easy to fly and. While the f 16 was designed as daytime visualrange dogfighter, f 35 was always intended to be a multirole aircraft with primary focus on airtoground missions and limited airtoair performance. Mr hicks also warned the committee that comparisons made of the f35 with other aircraft are. How does the f21 fighter jet compare to the f22 and f35.
The f35 lightning has been the air forces sole new fighter program since 2009, when the f22 raptor program was prematurely terminated. The f22 is definitely an amazing plane that deserves a lot of spotlight, but the f35 is no slouch. F22 and f35 are able to be guided by awacs, or other jets with datalink capability, with their. Why pilots prefer the f35 by james dunnigan july 20, 20. Introduction f35 is intended to replace the f16 and is promoted as f16s successor. In other words, the cost of one f35 is roughly twice what the federal government spends on npr and planned. Two things set the f22 engines apart from the f35 engine. Comparing chengdu j20 with f22, f35 and supak fa or t50. The only thing that might kill a new f22 fighter for. In reality boths jets with radar on will detect each other at the same time and same distance. The f35 sounds different than current legacy aircraft in terms of its tone. Just allow the f22 to be exported to japan already by tyler rogoway posted in the. Niemi has eight years in the cockpit of an f22 and is one of the few air force pilots who is qualified in both the raptor and the f35 lightning ii. As we reported last year, the debate between f35 supporters and critics became more harsh in july 2015, when war is.
Two things set the f 22 engines apart from the f 35 engine. Jan 04, 2011 comparing chengdu j20 with f 22, f 35 and supak fa or t50. Nash vickers both said a comparison of the radarabsorbing f 35 to its nimble but less stealthy twinengine f 22 cousin might not reveal the whole story. Compared to previous stealth designs like the f117, the f22 is less reliant on ram, which are maintenanceintensive and susceptible to. Aviation week reports that the f35 rcs is 30 dbsm or.
F 22 and f 35 are able to be guided by awacs, or other jets with datalink capability, with their. F22a carries twice as many ai rtoair missiles as the f35a f22a tactically employs at nearly twice the altitude and at 50% greater airspeed than the f35a gives airtoair missiles a 40% greater employment range and increased lethality increases airtoground weapons employment range f22a can control more than twi ce the battle space of the f35a f22a aesa radar has more tr elements than f35 radar. The reason the f22 wins so easily is a combination of excellent instantaneous turn rate to get shots off, because of thrust. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. By comparison, the official description of the stealth level of the f35 is that of a metal golf ball.
Russias new t50 fighter still cant compete with the f35. The f35 is likely to get first visual pickup because of its smaller size, so id probably give it the advantage so long as it was in a position to catch the supercruising f22. Pbl award pkg 2008 system f22 defense acquisition university pdf. The most obvious difference between the two aircraft is the f22 employs two engines and the f35 only uses one. Jul 01, 2015 to say the f35 cant beat an f16 in bfm is shortsighted and sensationalist at best, so lets break down the truth in a recent engagement. Lm made both f 35 and f 22 thus they will know the characteristics of their own aircraft, it alot more valid for them to say which one they made is more stealthy or faster, by contrast china doesnt make f 22, doesnt make f 35, doesnt make pakfa, they just recently speculated to have aesa radar, it completely unreasonable to claim they. Russia doesnt compare the t50 to the f35, preferring to compete with the f22, but the f35 is the future of america and its allies. Aug 05, 2016 joint strike fighter jsf documentary from 2003 lockheed x35 f35 and boeing x32. F35 joint strike fighter and the f22 raptor popular. Alternatively, the f35 could just hit the f22s airfield with its greater range of air to ground ordinance and. While the f22 might be holding a better hand when it comes to stealth, the russians have the edge in maneuverability. It is also claimed that the eurofighter is a better air dominance fighter. The first nontest pilot to fly the f35, berke commanded marine fighter attack training squadron 502 at marine corps air station beaufort, south carolina. The f 21 is a slightly modified version of the 2012 f 16v block 70 viper.
Apr 04, 2019 in the following quote, note that the f 35 is claimed to be more stealthy than the f 22. Watch the f35 fire its gun pod for the very first time. F22 raptor vs f35 lightning ii comparison bvr dogfight. As far as public knowledge goes, there has only been one runin between these two flagship fighters. General dynamics f 16 fighting falcon variants wikipedia and f 21 watch the short video the f 21 is truly a version of a f 16 and is not related in anyway to the f 22 or. With the f35 lightning, this fighter sees better, has more range, and is stealthier than any of its predecessors. F 35 lightning ii vs f 16e fighting falcon block 60.
The f35 is better than any other fighter aircraft, including the f22, for airtoground strike missions. A comparison between su35 and f22 which one is the best. Before printing this document, highlight the table of contents and hit f9 to update the page numbers. F35 lightning ii vs mirage 2000e comparison bvr dogfight. The f22 for instance only uses ram on leading edges and the f35s carbon fiber are able to. Heres how the f35 stacks up to russia and chinas 5thgeneration aircraft. But piloted planes retain an air of necessity in the.
On hand is the f35 lightning ii, renowned as the most expensive program for weapon procurement while on the other hand is f22, known for air dominance. While the f16 was designed as daytime visualrange dogfighter, f35 was always intended to be a multirole aircraft with primary focus on airtoground missions and limited airtoair performance. F35 lightning ii vs f16e fighting falcon block 60 comparison. Jul 29, 2016 watch the f 35 fire its gun pod for the very first time. So the f 35 will never see a su 35 on radar screen before the su 35 see the f 35. Though several sources claim the f22f35 hybrid is a frontrunner for the f3 program, the national interests dave majumdar argues that the. What do you think about the comparison of these fighters against j20.
Ive noticed that the f35 joint strike fighter and the f22 raptor, both of which are in development by lockheed martin, look strikingly similar. Pdf the f22 raptor and the chengdu j20 are fighter aircrafts capable of supersonic flight, stealth and extreme maneuverability using in. The radar cross section rcs of a target is defined as the effective area intercepting an amount of incident power which, when scattered isotropically, produces a level of reflected power at the. By comparison, the f35 attains spectrum dominance by. Perhaps the most important question is the type of engine powering the j20. What is now the great advantage of stealth datalink is the answer. In comparison with the f22 and the f35, us fifthgeneration fighters, the j20 has a bigger fuel capacity giving it greater range and a larger store of weapons carried internally, brock said. In december of 2017, two f22s engaged two su25s over syria after the russian jets crossed the deconfliction line entering territory claimed by the u. May 31, 2011 air force association f22 versus f35 comparison 1. Were talking about the f 22 raptor and the f 35 lightning ii they cornerstones of our air superiority. Now i have tried repeatedly to prove him wrong but he keeps comming up with info about how an f14 can track a f22s heat signature and fire on it before the f22 could fire, how the f14 can manuver better than the f22, and all sorts of other info that, to me, sounds bogus.
May 15, 2008 an article on the differences between x 35 and f 35. Russia doesnt compare the t50 to the f 35, preferring to compete with the f 22, but the f 35 is the future of america and its allies. He is the only marine ever to have qualified to fly the f22 raptor and served as the f22 division commander at the air forces 422nd test and evaluation squadron. In the following quote, note that the f35 is claimed to be more stealthy than the f22. By comparison, the original f15 was built to serve only 5,000 hours.
Comparing chinas new stealth fighter with f22 and f35. Air force s original plan was for the f22 to be its highend air superiority. Here is a list of areas where the f22 and the f35 differ. It might not be the best air fighter, the best carrier fighter, or the best bomber, but it can do the 3 on a cheap platform that can be modified a lot easier. The f22 is considered superior to the f35 in counterair and destruction of enemy air defenses missions, but it costs twice as much to procure and operate. For our readers we present a comparison of f35 lightning ii vs f22 raptor. The most obvious difference between the two aircraft is the f 22 employs two engines and the f 35 only uses one. The f35 doesnt have the altitude, doesnt have the speed of the f22, but it can beat the f22 in stealth, hostage told me, the f35 is geared to go out and take down the surface. To say the f35 cant beat an f16 in bfm is shortsighted and sensationalist at best, so lets break down the truth in a recent engagement. A sidebyside comparison of the x 35 joint strike fighter prototype with the f 35 lightning ii production aircraft underscores the huge strides the jsf program has made transitioning from demonstration to development. In any event, the f35 will outclass a rafale, f15e, or eurofighter, but not the f22. Just allow the f 22 to be exported to japan already by tyler rogoway posted in the war zone. Avb, ea6b, fa18cd, fa18ef data from various technical reports aug 2002 2. Aug 18, 2018 more than a fighter jet, the f35s ability to collect, analyze and share data is a powerful force multiplier enhancing all airborne, surface and groundbased assets in the battlespace and.
Here is a list of areas where the f 22 and the f 35 differ. The answer is that the f35 cannot match the f22 as an air superiority fighterit was never designed as such. The f35 and advanced versions of the f18 super hornet are like apples and oranges both good choices. F35 joint strike fighter jsf program congressional research service summary the largest procurement program in the department of defense dod, the f35 lightning ii is a strike fighter aircraft being procured in different versions for the united states air force, marine corps, and navy. The b2s skin is absurdly expensive to maintain in comparison to the f22 or f35. Unit costs based a f35 buy of 183 and an f22 buy of 1763 would result in significantly greater f35 unit cost than current estimates. Heres how the f35 stacks up against russia and china. Air forces original plan was for the f22 to be its highend air superiority fighter while the f35 was designed to be primarily an airtoground strike aircraft, but one which could defend itself. Air force a new variant of the f22 raptor, equipped with the f35s more modern mission avionics. Lockheed pitching f22f35 hybrid to us air force defense one. The best comparison i can think of is being at the helm of ship without me really knowing what i am talking about im not a sailor.
Current dod plans call for acquiring a total of 2,456. How does the f117s stealth shape compare to the f35s. By comparison, the official description of the stealth level of the f 35 is that of a metal golf ball. Comparison of f35 lightning ii vs f22 raptor crew daily. The f 22 is definitely an amazing plane that deserves a lot of spotlight, but the f 35 is no slouch. F16, f15, and f22 data from afrl noise data handbook 3. I know that a lot of information regarding both airframes is classified, but given that we have high quality images of both the f 22 and the t50, i think we can make some reasonable assumptions, estimates, extrapolations, and comparisons about the merits of each aircrafts aerodynamic shape. Nash vickers both said a comparison of the radarabsorbing f35 to its nimble but less stealthy twinengine f22 cousin might not reveal the whole story. Incredible video of f35 shows its insane ability dropping. While the f22 is superior to the f35 in airtoair missions, the f35s airtoair capability is superior to all other fighters. Its important to note that the f15x would supplement, not replace, the f22, f35, or any future stealth jets. For our first comparison, we brought together two of the worlds most renowned fighter jets.
Sukhoi t50 cant compete with the f35 business insider. The f21 is a slightly modified version of the 2012 f16v block 70 viper. However, closer look reveals that this is not true. Difference between the f35 and the f22 military quotes. Two f119pw100 turbofan engines power the f 22 raptor. A norwegian pilot shared his experience flying mock aerial combat with the f35. He said he wanted to set the record straight on the lightning ii, once and for all.
The lockheed martin f22 raptor is a singleseat, twinengine, allweather stealth tactical. Objective comparison of f22s and the t50s aerodynamics. Table 19comparison of old apta and new apta with fighter targets cockpits. The f35 project has been troubled from the start and the future of jet planes is in doubt. Pdf comparative study of f22 raptor and chengdu j20. In order to keep costs under control and justify the industrial ramp up underway, participating countries need to sign order agreements soon.
664 869 1432 313 1573 700 941 1000 40 645 616 844 763 1000 952 850 79 910 629 1404 67 896 146 1486 1438 124 448 1331 480 93